Therapy & help
Talk therapy
Across 968 answers, 5.3% gave the top answer (a 10/10 or “changed my life”) and 50% said it helped a lot or more.
All answers · 968 answers
- Life-changing
- Big help
- Slight help
- Did nothing
- Made it worse
Have you tried it?
Only answer if you've tried Talk therapy. What did it do for you?
What is it?
Talk therapy is regular sessions with a psychologist or therapist, working through what is going on, without the fixed protocol that defines CBT or EMDR. It covers a wide range of approaches, and in practice what you get depends far more on the individual than on the label on their door.
The evidence has a consistent and slightly awkward finding behind it: the relationship with the therapist predicts the outcome better than the method does. It suits problems too diffuse to name, where the useful thing is not a technique but an hour a week with someone whose job is to notice the patterns you cannot see from inside them.
All answers
968 answers in total: 937 from surveys and 31 from this site.
- Life-changing: 5.3%, 51 votes
- Big help: 45%, 433 votes
- Slight help: 25%, 238 votes
- Did nothing: 17%, 164 votes
- Made it worse: 8.5%, 82 votes
By questionnaire
On this site · 31 answers
Surveys with all five answers · 937 answers from the SlateStarCodex 2019 survey
- Life-changing
- Big help
- Slight help
- Did nothing
- Made it worse
Survey answers are converted to these five answers. Each share above counts only the questionnaires that offered that answer, because not every survey offered all five. In the SlateStarCodex 2019 survey, a 10 out of 10 rating counts as “changed my life”.
What does a course involve?
Usually weekly and open-ended, and the first few sessions are mostly establishing what you are actually there for. Nothing much happens in them, which surprises people expecting a technique.
Changing therapist after a few sessions is normal rather than a failure. Given that fit predicts the outcome, staying with someone you don't click with is the expensive mistake, not the awkward conversation.
How do you get it?
Privately, through a health service with a waiting list, or through an employer scheme, and the price range between those is enormous.
The thing nobody tells you is that you are allowed to shop. Many therapists offer a short first call, and using it to ask how they work, rather than starting straight into your history, is the most useful twenty minutes in the process.
More in Therapy & help
Talk therapy ranks #5 of 5 in Therapy & help for life-changing.
- 1EMDR therapyEye movement desensitisation and reprocessing, a therapy used for trauma and PTSD. How people who tried EMDR rate it, from no use at all to life-changing.25%57 votes
- 2Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)A structured, short-term therapy for unhelpful thoughts and habits, often for anxiety. How people who tried CBT rate it, from no use at all to life-changing.20%1,026 votes
- 3Dialectical behaviour therapy (DBT)Skills-based therapy for handling intense emotions, self-harm and crises. How people who did DBT rate it, from no use at all to life-changing.17%98 votes
- 4Psychodynamic therapy / psychoanalysisLonger therapy digging into your past and your patterns, in the Freudian tradition. How people who went rate it, from no use at all to life-changing.17%310 votes
- 5Talk therapyThis pageRegular sessions with a psychologist or therapist to talk through what's going on. How people who went rate it, from no use at all to life-changing.15%968 votes
Know someone who's tried Talk therapy?
Every answer makes this page more accurate. Share it with people who've tried Talk therapy, whether it changed their life or did nothing for them.
Self-reported experiences, not medical advice. High scores mean people reported strong positive effects. They do not mean something is safe, effective long-term, or appropriate for you. Self-reports can miss delayed harms, dependence, withdrawal, side effects, and selection bias. Don't start or stop a medication because of a chart.
You might also like
All projects